Decision of the constitutional court of Russia on pension. Pension legislation at the decisions of the constitutional court of the Russian Federation
From the materials, refer, 07.02.2018, the applicant was transferred to the pension fund from the application for the return of the paid insurance premiums in the amount of 47,331 rubles. Decided on 19.02.2018, the pension fund moved the amount of insurance premiums paid back from the refunded sums of insurance contributions to the payment of the sums of insurance premiums paid on the insurance pension. Vvazhayuchi vіdmovu vіdmova vіdmі vіdmі vіdmі vіdnі vіdnі vіdnі zaplіnіh izplіhіh insurance payments іn illegal i іn such, scho іnteresі
FSS installation
FSS RF not submitted
prove, for the obviousness of such actions, the fact that the fact that it is actually zdіysnyuvanoї pridpriєmstvo dіyalnistyu є "rent of budіvelnih cars and statkuvannya" allowed you to recognize the increase in the insurance rate, which is the 22nd class of professional risk. The judges established the impossibility of the actual imposition of a suspension of this type of activity from a connection with a new day on the right of authority All court practice on this topic »Zagalnopravovі ambush and principles of podatkuvannya
Understand the tribute and collection
The principle of the lawful introduction of a tribute
Insurance contract
ABOUT VIDMOVI IN PRINYATTI BEFORE LOOKING SCARGA
GROMADYANINA FOKIN VALERY VASILOVICH ON THE DAMAGE OF YOGO
OF CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS BY PARAGRAPH 1 OF ARTICLE 29 AND PROVISIONS
STATT 30 OF THE FEDERAL LAW "ON LABOR PENSIONS
RUSSIAN FEDERATION"
In the applicant’s opinion, contesting the norms do not allow zarakhuvat to the total length of service, necessary for the appointment of a rozrakhankovy rozmіru labor pension, the period of initiation from the middle and higher initial mortgages, the period of military service after the call to the pіlgаnіy zaklyuchenі ; and takozh obchisliti rozrahunkovy pensіyny kapіtal Shlyakhov zbіlshennya ochіkuvanogo perіodu viplati trudovoї pensії for starіstyu at Quantity rokіv, SSMSC vіdsutnі at priznachennі dostrokovoї pensії to zagalnovstanovlenogo of the Pension vіku scho pogіrshuє Yogo pensіyne zabezpechennya, obmezhuє right boats Zahist that superechit statte 19 (Chastain 1) 46 (parts 1 and ), 55 (parts 2 and ), 118 (part 1) and 123 (part 3) of the Constitution of the Russian Federation.
2. The Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation, after reviewing the submission of materials, does not know the basis for accepting the money before consideration.
In connection with the change in the order of calculation of labor pensions, old-age pensions, the date of recruitment of rank of the Federal Law "On Labor Pensions of the Russian Federation", tobto. On September 1, 2002, the legislator, at Article 30 of the Federal Law, having established for insuring the rights of the conversion of their pension rights, the way of converting the pension capital for the insurance formula, the warehouse element, which is the calculation of the wages of the pension fund in the established order. For osіb, the pension was recognized as being before the appointed date, the repayment of labor pensions established by the norms of the Law of the Russian Federation "On State Pensions in the Russian Federation", you can follow the rules, transfer clauses 3, 4 and 30 of the Federal Law "On Labor pensions from the Russian Federation". When tsomu in punktі 2 tsієї stattі, vsuperech zatverdzhennyu zayavnika, zakrіpleno dekіlka varіantіv viznachennya rozrahunkovogo rozmіru trudovoї pensії are insured osіb pitched 1 sіchnya 2002 rock, scho dozvolyaє zaznachenim pay special naybіlsh spriyatlivy varіant obchislennya rozmіru pensії she did not pereshkodzhaє realіzatsії Nabutov pensіynih rights.
Zocrema, stipulated by paragraph 3 of Article 30 of the Federal Law "On Labor Pensions in the Russian Federation" establishes a calendar procedure for calculating the total work experience, with which the rozrahunkovy rozmіr pension does not pay for the exchange. Paragraph 4 of Article 30 of the challenged Federal Law transferred the possibility of calculating the rozrokhunkovogo amount of pensions in the manner established by the legislation of the Russian Federation Stan on December 31, 2001. Tsya norm establishes the order of calculation of the total work experience, the zocrema from the beginning of the first period of the beginning of the first and second initial mortgages, and the provision for the exchange of the pension for the rozmіru of the singing sum (paragraph forty).
Scho stacking a paragraph of the third paragraph 5 of Stattі 30 of the Federal Law "About Labor Pensії in Rosіyskiyi Federation" in the pensions of the editor, then the Dane puts it, Scho puts out the specialty of the Commission of Roses Pensіynya Kapitalla, Yaki Buli, in Okami, Robiti Scho nailed ї right with the right to Voyo's view of the Labor experience, Z Irachwannovyzhi Zakii Svyysnyuvalasa Rosemira Pensіirny's Rights, Methods Committed by Roomіra by the Insurance Party of Labor Pensії, In addition, it's about Vіdpovіdnyy Robіt, Bulo is hidden on the Real_iz_yu Rasp and that one cannot be judged as such, which violates the constitutional rights of the people (Designated by the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation dated 29 March 2016 N 594-O).
In this rite, osporyuvanі PROVISIONS stattі 30 of the Federal law "About trudovі pensії in Rosіyskіy Federatsії" zakrіplyuyut order realіzatsії rights are insured osіb on pensіyne zabezpechennya vihodyachi of obranogo them naybіlsh spriyatlivogo varіanta obchislennya rozmіru pensії, spryamovanі on Obl_k їhnіh іnteresіv and takozh on zberezhennya rights Nabutov before the introduction of the named Federal Law into the law, and they cannot be considered as such that violate the rights of the people.
Under Article 30 of the Federal Law "On Labor Pensions in the Russian Federation," there was a systemic connection with other provisions of the Federal Law, including Article 17, 'Glasses) Stattі 29, Scho SkirmPurnut Sberry Visiting Romіра Pensії, visno-ї vіdpovyuyu to Ranische of genuine legislative, and Torzh Zi Stattay 12.1 Federal Law 17 Lipnya 1999 ROCK N 178-FZ "Pro Power Communication Dopcoming", Shaho stand up pay extra at times, even though the total amount of material security of a pensioner is less than the subsistence minimum of a pensioner in the subject of the Russian Federation.
Henceforth, there is no reason to believe that the constitutional rights of the applicant were violated by the offending provisions.
Virishennya nutrition assessment of pension rights V.V. Fokina with one-hour victories of various methods, transferred by law, the zocrema of the seniority for one rule, and the appointment of a rozrakhankovo rozmіru labor pension - for others, in addition to making changes to a decent legal regulation and falling within the competence of the Constitutional Federal Court of the Russian Federation.
Vyhodyachi z vikladenyi karuyuyuchisya paragraph 2 of article 43, part of the first article 79, that of the Federal Constitutional Law "On the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation", the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation
Significant:
1. Vіdmoviti in accepting the scarga of the gromadyan Fokіn Valeriy Vasilyovych, the shards won’t be able to comply with the Federal Constitutional Law “On the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation”, it’s possible until such a scarga to the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation is admissible.
2. Praise to the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation for tsієyu skarga residually that oskarzhennu not pіdlyagaє.
Head
Constitutional Court
Russian Federation
CONSTITUTIONAL COURT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION
DESIGNATION
FOR THE GROUP OF DEPUTATIONS
STATE DUMI ABOUT CONSTITUTIONAL REVISION
PROVISIONS OF THE FEDERAL LAW "ABOUT LABOR PENSIONS
RUSSIAN FEDERATION" I STATT 7 OF THE FEDERAL LAW
"ABOUT OBOV'YAZKOVE PENSION INSURANCE
RUSSIAN FEDERATION"
The Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation at the warehouse Golovi V.D. Zorkina, judge M.V. Bagla, N.S. Bondar, G.A. Gadzhiev, Yu.M. Danilova, L.M. Zharkova, G.A. Zhilina, S.M. Kazantseva, M.I. Kleandrov, A.L. Kononova, L.O. Krasavchikova, Yu.D. Rudkina, A.Ya. Slivi, V.G. Strekozova, O.S. Khokhryakova, B.S. Ebzeeva, V.G. Yaroslavtsev,
Having heard at the plenary session the judges S.M. Kazantsev, who, on the basis of Article 41 of the Federal Constitutional Law "On the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation", held a preliminary meeting with a group of deputies in the State Duma,
By setting:
1. At their request to the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation, a group of deputies of the Sovereign Duma to ask for recognition by those who do not respect 17, 18, 20, that the Constitution of the Russian Federation provisions of Articles 2, 11, 12, 14, 17, and Federal Law "About labor pensions of the Russian Federation". In the opinion of the applicants, with the help of the provisions, one can argue either that the pension rights of the citizens are changed earlier, and the concepts of "state pension", "labor pension", "adjustment of pensions", "smart the rent, indexation and pay pensions", "rozakhunkovy pension capital", in them. the rights of the majority of citizens are infringed.
CRIM, POWER 1 STATTІ 7 TO THE FEDERAL AGAINE "PERSON 1 STATE PERSIIN INSURAVENNA TO ROSІYSKIY FEDERY", SKIMA SPEY KATHEGORIA ACIA KATHEGORIA MUDADYAN, NODPOVІDAє 17, 18, 20 THIS CONSTITUTSIKI ROSІYSKO RODIYA.
2. GROUP OF MPUTATIVIVIE DUMMY DUMI OF THE INSTRUMENTS CONSTITUTUTSINIATSIATS Significant Kilkosti Regulations (B_lsha 200), it is not actually dedicated to paragraph 8 of the part of the Friend of the Federal Constitutional Act "about the Constitutional Court of the Federal Constitutional Act" about the Constitutional Court of Rosіyskiiii "Provision of the OblongTuvnya.
So, the applicants do not state why, in my opinion, they believe the unconstitutionality of Article 2 of the Federal Law "On Labor Pensions in the Russian Federation", as it is to avenge the main ones understood by unconstitutional. Proponaii Vnestati not vіdpovyiiiiiiiiiiiiiii Rosіyskiiiiiiii region PRESH STATTI 3 named federal law, Vonya Zgaduyut, Shaho Vіdpovy, to the rules, Shaho m_Siyi in Niy, Vyadyani Rosіyskoji Federation, Zastrakhovі Vіdpovyu to federal law "About Obovo Communication Pensiine" Pensіin " , to gain the right to a pension. In whose Poliakaє Non-Constituts_inіst Norma Vіdsylannya Stattі 6 of the Federal Law "About Labor Pensіi in Rosіyskiyiyii", Yaka stand upstairs, Ocho, the order of Finansuvanna Pereviki Pensіi to visit the Federal Law "Pro Oboko Pensіin insured in Rosіyskiyi Fedsi", I will not get the same. Forbidden by the Federal Law "On Labor Pensions in the Russian Federation", which establishes the right to an extended recognition of a labor pension, the applicants do not specify, as the very provisions of the statute establish a zhorstkishі, on your mind, mind the recognition of a labor pension.
At the request, it is confirmed by paragraph 1 of Article 7 of the Federal Law "On Obligatory Pension Insurance in the Russian Federation" and paragraph 2 of Article 11 of the Federal Law "On Labor Pensions in the Russian Federation" insurance experience, the rights of citizens are interchanged: paragraph 1 of Article 7 of the Federal Law "On Obligation Pension Insurance in the Russian Federation" - vouchers of wine are not included up to the number of insured students, civil servants and others, and paragraph 1 of the Federal Law "On Labor Pensії in Rosіyskiyiyiya ", Zgіdim Zakim Zazalovі in Tsіy Stattі Nestrakhovі Periodi to catch up to the insurance experience, Tіlki Yakschko voni represented by ABO for them, Perniodi Roboti Abo Іnschennostei, at Perigod Zdіysnennya Сакої и опровый бериский светски - oskilki by virtue of the Law of Ukraine "On state pensions in the Russian Federation", w oh, until the recruitment of rank by challenging Federal laws, for the inclusion of the same periods, the work experience of such additional minds did not count. In addition, the Federal Law "On Labor Pensions in the Russian Federation", stipulates for any calculation of the insurance period necessary for gaining the right to a labor pension, to be carried out according to the calendar order for all categories of pensioners, destroying the applicants' idea, constitutional rights, exercising in the districts of Kraynoi Pivnochi and in the areas close to them, participants in the liquidation of an accident at the Chornobyl nuclear power plant, rich mothers and citizens of other categories, although earlier they had been counted for some non-insurance periods before their labor internship.
Tim, the applicants themselves are unprimed to interpret the insurance experience and the length of service by the institutes. Under the insurance experience, about which there is a zocrema, and the Federal Law "On labor pensions in the Russian Federation", as well as paragraph 1 of Article 7 of the Federal Law "On ob'yazkove pension insurance in the Russian Federation", it is understood that the right to work pension total trivality of periods of work and (or) other activities, for which insurance contributions were paid up to the Pension Fund of the Russian Federation, as well as other periods, which are insured up to the insurance period; This value is added to the rozmіr labor pension. Ponyattya "zagalny seniority" zastosovuєtsya in the name of the Federal Law for viznachennya order obchislennya rozrahunkovogo rozmіru trudovoї pensії, the value rozrahunkovogo of the Pension kapіtalu that stazhovogo koefіtsієnta scho vplivaє on rozrahunkovy rozmіr trudovoї pensії and takozh vrahovuєtsya at dostrokovomu priznachennі pensіy okremim kategorіyam gromadyan (paragraph 2) and 4 articles 30 of the Federal Law "On labor pensions in the Russian Federation"). Also, the applicants actually oscarzhuetsya constitutional change in the order of the shape of the infamous work experience, established by the Federal Law "On Labor Pensions in the Russian Federation" and not insurance (Article 11 of the Federal Law "On Labor Pensions in the Russian Federation", the Federal Law "On Pensions insurance in the Russian Federation").
In this rank, a group of deputies of the State Duma will be asked in part to reconsider the constitutional provisions of Articles 2, 11, and the Federal Law "On Labor Pensions in the Russian Federation" and Article 7 of the Federal Law "On Obligation Pension Insurance in the Russian Federation", not may be adopted by the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation before consideration, but the evidence does not support clause 8 of the other part of Article 37 of the Federal Constitutional Law "On the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation".
3. 15, 16, and the Federal Law "On Labor Pensions in the Russian Federation" establishes the expiration of labor pensions for old age, labor pensions for disability, labor pensions for the year, and the order of calculation, as well as the procedure for determining correction of rozmіrіv labor pensions.
In the opinion of the applicants, their enshrinement of social security does not guarantee the skin pensioner the right to a sufficient life for a new and yogo family, but Articles 7, that (part 1) of the Constitution of the Russian Federation, and international cultural law are violated; the right of a person to a "sufficient living wage", which is recognized by the powers - participants in the International Pact on economic, social and cultural rights, corresponding to the obligatory language of the state, to establish such a minimum pension amount, not to the budget of the Pension Fund of the Russian Federation.
According to the words, the claims, according to Suti, we propose knowingly zb_lshiti Rosemіr Mіnіmalo Pension, I want to locate Constitutoin_st, paragraph 8 of Stattі 14, Item 4 Stattі Statti 15 T. Station 4 Stattі 16 Federal Law "Pro Labor Pensії in Russia the amount of the basic part and the insurance part of the labor pension for old age (as well as for disability and the second anniversary) cannot be less than 660 rubles per month, and the entire sum of the normative provisions of the titles of the articles (headline 92 paragraph).
Constitutsіya Rosіyskoji, VІDPOVIKODU to Tsіli sociallyland dawn part 1) Garantyuchi Skin Socinal Oblobrechennya in Starosti, at once Khvorki, Іnvalіdnostі, random of the yearvalnik, for the Vigor of D_tei, in the past Breas rights, the establishment of pensions, up to the competence of the legislator. To whom does the international pact about economic, social and cultural rights correspond, which, binding the obligations of the state, to secure the skin of the people of a sufficient life, do not specify, but you yourself should come and live for the security of such an equal.
Oskіlki virіshennya supply about zbіlshennya mіnіmalnogo rozmіru trudovoї pensії not vіdnositsya to povnovazhen the Constitutional Court of Rosіyskoї Federatsії, peredbachenih statte 125 Konstitutsії Rosіyskoї Federatsії that statte 3 Federal konstitutsіynogo law "About Konstitutsіyny Court Rosіyskoї Federatsії" RFQ groupies deputatіv State Dumi in chastinі scho stosuєtsya perevіrki konstitutsіy Articles 14, 15, 16 of the Federal Law "On Labor Pensions in the Russian Federation", also cannot be adopted by the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation before consideration.
4. Violation of the right to social security, as well as the equanimity of the citizens, a group of deputies in the State Duma vbachay in that for those who are retired until they gain rank by the Federal Law "On labor pensions in the Russian Federation", the maximum allowance for pensions () to be separated by a sum of 1504 rubles, although such a boundary is not established for a later recognized pension; discrimination in the right to social security is punishable, for their assertions, to those who for osіb, yakі otrimuyut pensions vіdpovіdno up to the Federal law "On the state pension security", іsnuіє іnsha, nizh for pensioners, scho zabezpechuyusya by law in the Federal Republic of Uzbekistan, the system that indexation of pensions, which allows you to pay a pension from the other person.
At the request, it is stated that the regulatory power of the normative state is offset by the totality of the norms of Chapter 4 of the Federal Law "On labor pensions in the Russian Federation" (Article 14 - that yoga
Polant of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation Vіd 24.09.2012 N 1800-O "For the Sverdlovsky District Court of Mist Kostromy about Perevіrkka Constitutsіjinostі Partica of Officon Stattі 43 Rosіyski Federal District Law" About Pensіin Osiskinnya Osisb, Yaki was held by VIYSKOV, service in the internal office authorities, held by the control authorities for the volume of narcotic drugs and psychotropic speeches, the establishment of the bodies of the criminal and vikonavcho system, and those families "
CONSTITUTIONAL COURT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION
DESIGNATION
At the request of the Sverdlovsk District Court of the city of Kostroma on the verification of the constitutionality of part of the second article 43 of the Law of the Russian Federation "On the pension provision of persons held by military service, service in the bodies of the internal affairs, state fire service, organs for controlling drug trafficking and psychotropic substances, institutions and AUTHORITIES OF THE CRIMINAL-VIKONAVCHOY SYSTEM, THAT IX SIMEY"
The Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation at the warehouse Golovi V.D. Zorkina, judge K.V. Aranovsky, A.I. Boytsova, N.S. Bondar, G.A. Gadzhiev, Yu.M. Danilova, L.M. Zharkova, G.A. Zhilina, S.M. Kazantseva, M.I. Cleanrova, S.D. Knyazeva, O.M. Kokotova, L.O. Krasavchikova, S.P. Mavrina, N.V. Melnikova, Yu.D. Rudkina, N.V. Seleznyova, O.S. Khokhryakova, V.G. Yaroslavtsev,
Having looked at the feasibility of accepting the petitions of the Sverdlovsk District Court of the city of Kostroma before looking at the meetings of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation,
by setting:
1. Rosiyski Ukraine to Constitutsіynyy District District District Court of Kostromi Svordlskiy District Court of Missta Kostromi Oscaruє Constitutsіsti Different Party Stattі 43 LEGISH DEPARTMENT 12 LUTOVYY 1993 ROCK N 4468-1 "About Pensіin Osіb, Yaki held VIYSKOVA service, service in the internal office authorities, keeping anti-burning service, bodies with control over the volume of narcotic drugs and psychotropic speeches, establishments and bodies of the criminal and vikonavcho system, those families ", which is in the editorial office, which gained rank from 1 September 2012 given the statistics, which is insured when the pension is calculated from 1 September 2012, the year at the expense of 54 thousand rubles, and starting from 1 September 2013, the year will be increased by 2 thousand rubles to reach 100 thousand rubles; due to the adjustment of the inflation rate (slower prices) by the federal law on the federal budget for the last financial year and the planning period, a wider increase can be set for the second financial year at the expansion, which exceeds 2 hundredths.
As yelling at the submission of materials, the citizen V.M. Tarasenko, who was from 1 September 1975 to 19 December 2000, having served in the military and took a pension for his service, and also O.M. Shutov, a pensioner of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation since 1996.
Sverdlovsk District Court of the city of Kostromi, a joint draft about those who are part of the other article 43 of the Law of the Russian Federation "On pension security for employees, who served in the military service, service in the bodies of internal affairs, the State anti-burning services of the narcotics departments, drug control agencies for drug control , establishing the bodies of the criminal and vikonavchoi system, that їх families "does not comply with articles 1, 2, 15, 17 (parts 1 and 2), 18, 19 (parts 1 and 2), 54 (part 1) and 55 (parts 2 and 3) the Constitution of the Russian Federation, having returned to the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation with a request for re-verification of constitutionality, pleading the right of V.M. Tarasenko was praised on the 5th day of 2012, and at the right O.M. Shutov - praised on the 25th day of 2012.
On the absoluteness of the allegation, SHEY, SHEY, SHEY IN TOY MІRI, SHEYSKOVYZBOVTSIKOVA, SHEY NADІYISHIKOVLY SERVICE AT 1 SCHOYN 2012 ROCK, I PRESIONERIVIV OSIBERS OSIBERS, SNIBLE TIM, SHEY be insured for the calculation of pensions, contrary to earlier established norms.
2. Constitutsіya Rosіyskoi Fedecils, progress Rosіyski Fedeitia Socially I donate, in the yakiy, Turatua Tu is a healthy people, take the maintenance of Pіdtrimka SMM'ї, Maternity, Batkivsuity, the diet, Іnvalіv ta Littіh Gurgodyan, to join the Social System of Social Services, stand upwards and other guarantees of social protection (article 7, part 2), guaranteeing skin social security for a lifetime, in case of ailments, disabilities, spending a year for the rehabilitation of children and in other conditions established by law (article 39, part 1).
The constitutional right to social security includes the right to deprivation of pensions from the lawful states and states. Under Tsoma Constitutsіya Rosіyskoiiiiii, Non-Overhead, Specno, I worked, the order of Nadnya Pensіy, - Perevnі Pensіїi, the Social Dopcomer, Vіdpovyky to їїry Stattі 39 (Partial 2), stand up with the law (Postanov Constitutsіynyy Cude Rosіyskoi Fedsion
N 6-P). Depending on the law, the legal substantiation of the recognition of pensions, their calculation, the procedure for calculating and paying, the legislator has the right to establish different pension systems from the specifics of the labor and service activities of the citizens.
Federal zakonodavets, dіyuchi in furrows nadanih Yomou povnovazhen on vikonannya Konstitutsії Rosіyskoї Federatsії zakrіpiv in Zakonі Rosіyskoї Federatsії "About pensіyne zabezpechennya osіb, SSMSC were vіyskovu service, service in bodies vnutrіshnіh right, Derzhavnіy protipozhezhnіy sluzhbі, bodies of control over obіgom narkotichnih zasobіv that psychotropic rechovin , establish that the organs of the criminal and criminal system, that їх families "substantiate and realize the realization of the right to a pension of those appointed to new people who are challenged for similar parameters in the form of labor pensions: for them, zokrema, such a form of sovereign social security has been transferred, like a pension Rockіv, Shah, admitted for the appearance of Vіdpovy Okykovskosvzhbovtsіv, and Finananisvnaya Pensіi Zdіysyuzuyu for Rahunukov Kostev federal budget (snapped by the Constitutional Court of Rosіyskoi Federation N 437-Oh, Vіd 23 Vesna 2010 ROK N 1152-O- Oh, date 26 May 2011 date N 605-O-O and date 29 ver spring 2011 rock N 1040-O-O).
Pensі's for Ognvіdnіstyu, Shah, admitted by Persias, Yaki passed by VIYSKOVA service, and Torzії с arrive at the booster to members of ~ SiMyi at a rosh roshin, at the warehouse of the VІDPOVII to the part of the Persion Stattі 43 of Ukraine, Yaki passed the military service, service in the bodies of internal affairs, the State anti-burning service, bodies for the control of the volume of narcotic drugs and psychotropic speeches, institutions and bodies of the criminal-viconal system, and those families "are insured in accordance with the procedure prescribed by the Order of the Russian Academy of Sciences, salary of the Federal , salary for military ranks (without raising the salary increase for service in the distant, high-ranking professions and in other special minds) and a six-thousand-thousand-a-half bonus for the services of the rokiv, including the payment for the service index of penny security. When tsomu ponyattya "Penny zabezpechennya for obchislennya pensії vіyskovosluzhbovtsyam" vіdrіznyaєtsya od ponyattya "Penny zabezpechennya vіyskovosluzhbovtsіv", scho viznachaєtsya zakonodavstvom about the status vіyskovosluzhbovtsіv, she Got samostіyne normative values for tsіley obchislennya pensії that її pereglyadu vіyskovim pensіoneram (Viznachennya Konstitutsіynogo4 rock N 429-O) . Of the wisdom of the objasses і's specialty of legal acquisition of Vіyskovosvizhbovtsіv, yaki, on Vіdmin Vіd Osіb, Zvіlnih z Vіyskovo, to contract Vikonuvati Obokovka, pov'jaznі znevydnіsti Vincannya deliberates Sanctivities from beware of mischievous a risk for life and health, as well as zdіysnyuyut diyalnіst, sprjamovana on the constant advancement of qualifications and the thoroughness of their professional training.
3. From the 1st of September 2012, having gained rank Federal Law dated 7th leaf fall, 2011 date N 306-FZ "On the penny of the security of the military servicemen and the payment of okremih payments." Vstanovlena CIM Federal law novel system trumpery zabezpechennya osіb scho passing vіyskovu service peredbachayuchi digit zbіlshennya salary trumpery utrimannya vіyskovosluzhbovtsіv i zmіnyuyuchi warehouse schomіsyachnih that іnshih dodatkovih viplat scho vklyuchayutsya to trumpery zabezpechennya, spryamovana on zabezpechennya vіdpovіdnostі rіvnya Pay pratsі vіyskovosluzhbovtsіv that efektivnosti vikonannya military servicemen obov'yazkіv military service, stimulating them to a permanent perfection in the profession.
Immediately after the reforms were carried out, before legislation was introduced on pension security, military service, a provision was introduced to establish new rules for the form of penny security for the calculation of pensions. Vіdpovіdno to zaznachenih rules of 1 sіchnya 2012 roku viznachennya rozmіru pensії ladies, SSMSC were vіyskovu service that members їh sіmey zdіysnyuєtsya on osnovі vstanovlenih chinnim zakonodavstvom that vrahovanih in rozmіrі 54 vіdsotkіv scho vklyuchayutsya to trumpery zabezpechennya for obchislennya pensіy okladіv for vіyskovimi Posada that okladіv , as well as the sum of a sixty-six bonus for the service of a year. When tsomu of 1 sіchnya 2013 roku penny zabezpechennya for obchislennya pensіy ladies, SSMSC were vіyskovu service that members їh sіmey of metoyu dosyagnennya 100 vіdsotkіv Yogo rozmіru pіdlyagaє schorіchnomu zbіlshennyu 2 vіdsotki abo have bіlshomu obsyazі (fallow od rіvnya іnflyatsії) vіdpovіdno to federal law about the federal budget for the Chergovy financial period and the planning period.
3.1. Yak neodnorazovo vkazuvav Konstitutsіyny Court Rosіyskoї Federatsії, sama himself zmіna the method viznachennya rozmіrіv quiet chi іnshih penny viplat - for dotrimannya konstitutsіynih printsipіv spravedlivostі, rіvnostі, proportsіynostі and takozh stabіlnostі that garantovanostі rights gromadyan - Je prerogative of zakonodavtsya (Holds od 19 chervnya 2002 roku N 11 -P, dated November 27, 2008 year N 11-P, praised on April 11, 2002 year N 191-O, dated April 16, 2007 year N 375-O-P and in. Zdіysighing such a branch, ticking the principle of pіdtrimki Dovіri Vuddyan to the law of the DIY DIYEY, Yaky Dyubchasnnya Rosumnoi Stub_lnosti Legal Regimula, the non-apatomist of the removal of Dovilny Zmіn to Chinno Systems Norms (decree 24 grass 2001 ROCK N 8-P N 2-P and in.).
Zmenshivshi rozmіr trumpery zabezpechennya scho schodo vrahovuєtsya rozmіru pensіy ladies, zvіlnenim of vіyskovoї service, Zi 100 vіdsotkіv to 54 vіdsotkіv, zakonodavets peredbachiv scho obchislennya pensіy zdіysnyuєtsya on osnovі new - vischogo - trumpery zabezpechennya, zabezpechivshi CIM zbіlshennya obsyagu oderzhuvanih gromadyanami pensіy. During the preparation of the draft Federal Law "About a penny of security of military servicemen and taxes on them," as it was clear from the explanatory note before the new one, it was planned to increase pensions by an average of 50 - 70 hundred rubles, according to the norms of the previous legislation.
When zaprovadzhennі new legal regulyuvannya scho stosuєtsya oblіku trumpery zabezpechennya for obchislennya pensіy ladies, SSMSC were vіyskovu service that members їh sіmey, vіdpovіdno to the principle stabіlnostі legal regulyuvannya garantuєtsya (Chastina 1 stattі 5 of the Federal law "About Penny zabezpechennya vіyskovosluzhbovtsіv that nadannya їm okremih viplat ") savings reached by September 1, 2012, equal to the current pension security. Zaznachena norm zokrema, zakrіplyuє zberezhennya rozmіrіv pensіy, vstanovlenih vіdpovіdno to zakonodavstva Rosіyskoї Federatsії scho dіyalo until the day of dialed chinnostі Federal Law "On the one penny zabezpechennya vіyskovosluzhbovtsіv nadannya їm okremih viplat" in razі zmenshennya rozmіrіv priznachenih name of the special pensіy in zv'yazku h Chinnosti raid by the Federal Law of the Federal Law of the Federal Law of the Federal Law 8 of the Falls 2011 ROCK N 309-FZ "Pro Showing Zmіn to Okrahimi Aktіv Rosіyskoi Fedeita Ta Vannanny such, Scho plunged the Chinn_st, Okhareih Posted by the legislative acts of Rosіyskoi federal to the federal law" About the penny security of the military servicemen and the amount of taxes paid by them" and the Federal Law "On Social Guarantees for Defenders of the Internal Affairs Authorities of the Russian Federation and Changes to the Limits of Legislative Acts of the Russian Federation".
According to Pensi's rules, Со СОо СО С 1 Січня січный хорочный почальный повещение механімение перественный подничный поденичный обенговный подение поисское персіна ї и и сісей, Taiskii service, Tu members of ї іmäi, Tosiyi.
Such a rank, ordered by Nazvazyuchi to the zinage of the pengedness of the percentage of a pennum of a penbed slaughter, Scho eneficiously at the Communications Pensіy Pensi, Zh SMIME services, is hidden on Zb_lneshnya. Tse Povny mіroyu vіdpovіdaє peredbachenomu statte 1 lands about the order of the Pension zabezpechennya vіyskovosluzhbovtsіv that їh sіmey that sovereign strahuvannya vіyskovosluzhbovtsіv powers - uchasnits Spіvdruzhnostі Square Powers od 15 Travnia 1992 rock rule about those scho rіven of the Pension zabezpechennya vіyskovosluzhbovtsіv that їh sіmey, yaky vstanovlyuєtsya vіdpovіdno to please the pro SOCIALNIA TA REVERSIA GARANTA, OSIBOVYOVYUZBOVTSIKOVOE, OSIS, TA CERIME ВІХ имей від 14 Lyutogo 1992 ROCK, I can't Betyo, Introduced by the establishments of the number of RSRs, and Tlomachennoye Valida, formulated by the Tlumber Friendship of the Independent Powers, which was decided by N 01-1/2-08 dated February 6, 2009 the order of recognition pension limits established by national legislation.
Oskіlki innocence in nutrition about the constitutionality of part of another article 43 to the Law of the Russian Federation "On pension security for individuals who have served in the military service, service in the bodies of internal affairs, the State anti-burning service, bodies for the control of the obi-tropic organs of the narcotic drug vikonavchoi system, that yogo family" vіdsutnya, the request of the Sverdlovsk district court of the city of Kostroma is impossible to know adopted by the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation before looking.
Vykhodyachy z vikladeniyusya paragraph 2 of the first part of the article 43, part of the first article 79, articles 96 and 97 of the Federal Constitutional Law "On the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation", the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation
Significant:
1. Visnati washing the Sverdlovsky district court of Mist Kostroma, I don't piangut the departure of Rosіyski's Saddannі, osskіlki for the Vishennia, the Patimna delivered by the statement of 71 of the Federal Constitutional Law "about the Constitutional Court of Rosіyskoi Federation" Pіdsumkovoy Rischnya "
2. Praise to the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation for these requests is not enough to be insulted.
Head
Constitutional Court
Russian Federation
The Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation at the warehouse Golovi V.D. Zorkina, judge M.V. Bagla, N.S. Bondar, G.A. Gadzhiev, Yu.M. Danilova, L.M. Zharkova, G.A. Zhilina, S.M. Kazantseva, M.I. Kleandrov, A.L. Kononova, L.O. Krasavchikova, N.V. Seleznyova, A.L. Slivi, V.G. Strekozova, O.S. Khokhryakova, B.S. Ebzeeva,
having heard at the plenary session the visnovok of judges M.S. Bondar, G.A. Hajiyeva and O.S. Khokhryakova, they were carried out on the basis of Article 41 of the Federal Constitutional Law "On the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation" of the front wedding of the gromadyanka P.F. Enborisova,
by setting:
1. At the scary bulky woman P.F. Enborisovoe entrusted the constitutionality of paragraph 8 of Article 14 of the Federal Law dated December 17, 2001 "On labor pensions in the Russian Federation", for example, the amount of the basic insurance part of the labor pension for old age cannot be less than 66. On the applicant’s thought, the name of the statute, which allowed the establishment of her labor pension for old age lower than the subsistence minimum in the sub'єktі Russian Federation, devona living, using the individual's age, actually allows supertimina ), 18, 20 (part 1) and 21 (part 2) of the Constitution of the Russian Federation, as well as Article 11 of the International Pact on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. How yelling at the submission of materials, the bulky woman P.F. Enborisova, 1929 to the fate of the people, I was a disabled person of the 2nd group and may be over 27 years of hard work experience, including the fates of the Great Veteran War. Prior to the adoption of the Federal Law "On Labor Pensions in the Russian Federation", the applicant withdrew the pension for old age from the start in accordance with paragraph 15 of the Regulations on the procedure for recognizing and paying state pensions (approved by the Decree of the Radi Ministers of the SRSR on 3 Rapny 1950 of the Law No. dated 20 leaf fall 1990 year "About state pensions in the RRFSR" (with upcoming changes and additions). At the link with the recruitment of rank by the Federal Law "On labor pensions in the Russian Federation" (September 1, 2002) labor pension for old age P.F. Enborisova bula was charged at the rozmiri 771 rubles. 09 kop. (Її rozmіr at the time of consideration by the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation of the given scarga with the adjustment of periodic indexations to become 1185 rubles 36 kopecks).
For INFORMATSІYY MINSXTECTIONS OF SOCIAL DISTRIVES (LIST OF THE CHELYABINSKOVA 2004 ROCK), on Pіdtstі federal law Vіd 17 Lipnya 1999 ROCK "PRODUCED SOCIAL DETERMINE" TA EDITIONS Governor Chelyabіnskoї region Vіd 24 breasts 2003 ROCK N 549 "PRODUCTION OF VIPLATi Disposable Social Details low-income citizens and those who live in an important life situation, for the money of the regional budget" P.F. Enborisova, how to fall into the category of low-income self-living pensioners, average per capita incomes that are lower than the subsistence minimum established in the Chelyabinsk region, were one-time pennies, food and other help.
Vimoga P.F. Enborіsovoї about viznannya illegally Act reasonably teritorіalnogo upravlіnnya the Pension Fund Rosіyskoї Federatsії Mista Yuzhnouralska scho vіdmovilo їy in narahuvannі trudovoї pensії, yak b vіdpovіdala velichinі prozhitkovogo mіnіmumu in Chelyabіnskіy oblastі (at the time rozglyadu Spravi vіn becomes 1456 rubles). Yuzhnouralskim mіskim court Chelyabіnskoї zadovolennya. The Judicial Board at the civil rights of the Chelyabinsk Regional Court confirmed the decision to the court of the first instance, citing those that, due to pension legislation, do not transfer the calculation of the amount of the pension for old age, which varies from the subsistence minimum in the Federal Subject of Russia.
In this rank, the subject of review by the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation for the tsієyu skarga є provision of paragraph 8 of Article 14 of the Federal Law "On labor pensions in the Russian Federation", as an admission for osіb, yakі gave the right to cancel the labor pension for the old age pension Yaki Majut Working Studio, Nefіdnia for Renermaid Labor Pensіya for Star_Styu in Middesta II Grup, Veterans of Pratska Ty Tyluchniki Tila, Averaged Sumi Basic Party Party Outdoor Party Pension For Staristiu in Roomіrі, Minemum, Nіzh Pensіioner in the subject of the Russian Federation.
2. The Constitution of the Russian Federation will vote the Russian Federation as a social legal power, as it guarantees the equality of the rights and freedoms of the people and the bulk of the population and the policy of which is directed to the creation of minds, which ensures the daily life and development of the people (article 1, 1, part, article (article) article 18; article 19, parts 1 and 2).
The constitutional goals of the social policy of the Russian Federation impose obligations on the state's dbaty for the well-being of its citizens, their social protection; a person, as if by force of time, I will become healthy, otherwise I can’t lie down for other reasons, I can’t work and I can’t earn an income to secure a subsistence minimum for my own family and my family, I have the right to invest in the removal of external assistance, material assistance state and state (Decree of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation dated December 16, 1997 N 20-P on reconsideration of the constitutionality of the provisions of the sixth paragraph of paragraph 1 of article 28 of the Law of Ukraine "On the employment of the population in the Russian Federation"). Tom, Nadauchi skin law by Vlasnuyu Pracery, rivo rose-to-yaki to Pratsya for Be-Yako, not fenced by the law of ekonio Dіlnosti, robust the sobiiius for Існавуння, Constitutsіya Rosіyskoi and the Garantu, Socyalna Tomskin, for Vіkom, at once, the yearvoby, child care and in other ways established by law (article 34, part 1; article 37, part 1; article 39, part 1).
The legislator fixed the living standards of life, for the amendment of articles 7, 39 (parts 1 and 2), 71 (paragraphs "a", "c", "e") and 76 (part 1) of the Constitution of the Russian Federation, the subject of the jurisdiction of the Russian Federation, tobto. regional federal functions. Obov'yazky power to establish at the borders of the regulation that protection of the rights and freedoms of the people and the great man of equal opportunity to support the unprotected categories of the population throughout the Russian Federation is not excluded, prote, the right to sub'єktiv Russian Federation 1) , 76 (Part 2), 130 (Part 1) and 132 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation, transferring from their existing financial and economic opportunities, supplementing the form of social protection, including the provision of pension security, for the population in the public sector , as such decisions do not put additional goiters on the Russian Federation.
Danі Constitutsіinі Rzipovyannyh, Scho Tov'yazht Power of Socinal Zobov'yazhnia, in the Systems of the Norms of Constitutsії Rosіyskojo Federation, Nasampeed їna Articles 2 І 21 (Partial 1), promptly legal about Zakhіd Domanian Іndivіdіv, Yakі Majutvyostіyino Self-toathy material well-being, to guarantee material security, less on equal, necessary satisfaction with the basic living needs, and transfer the installation of a reliable regulatory mechanism to their satisfaction - as much as possible to the economic possibilities of the support of this stage of development.
2.1. p align="justify"> An important element of social security, recognized as being in need of income - for the additional creation of a system for accumulating results in your independent labor activity and a fair re-distribution of public material resources - saving up to retirement, without pension.
The federal legislator, up to the competence of the Constitution of the Russian Federation, to introduce the establishment of the pension system (Article 39, part 2), may, at his disposal, have sufficient freedom of trial, with the prescribed legal conditions, minds, and recognition of the order of calculation of pensions. Vodokhams Vіnnien Spіvіdnositi Priynyatі Rіshnya z Constitutsіinnoye the most significant principles of Pensіynya Ta Dіyati principles in the framework of the M_Inovo-Ropovy Zobov' Kazhnaya Rosіysko Federal region (Stattea 15, part 4; Statty 17, Part 1 Constitutsії Rosіyski & Fedsiї), Scho Vyolvyuty, Zokrema, Із Person of, the yak progoloshuє right kozhnoї Lyudin on sotsіalne zabezpechennya that on zdіysnennya neobhіdnih for pіdtrimki її gіdnostі that for vіlnogo rozvitku її osobistostі rights ekonomіchnіy, sotsіalnіy that kulturnіy Galuzo through poserednitstvo natsіonalnih zusil that mіzhnarodnogo spіvrobіtnitstva that vіdpovіdno to the structure is the resursіv kozhnoї powers (statte 22 ). In addition, the Russian Federation, as a participant in the International Pact on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, recognizes the right of the skin to a sufficient life for this and that yoga, which includes sufficient food, clothes, that life, that life without interruption, that mind yazuetsya to live long-term visits to the security of that right, which is important for the future of international cooperation, founded on the right (paragraph 1 of Article 11). Similar provisions are fixed at the countries adopted by the Inter-Parliamentary Assembly of the Powers - a participant in the Friendship of the Independent Powers of the Charter of social rights and guarantees of the citizens of the Independent Powers (Article 40) and the Charter of people of a frail age.
Instead of establishing international acts, it corresponds to the provision of the Constitution of the Russian Federation, which calls for adoption as a constitutional and legal criterion for legislative regulation of pension certificates of minds, which guarantee a year of specialty. Vannanny Gіdnostі OSO, VІDPOVIKUY TO THE RESOVYSKY OF THE CONSTRUCTORY COUNTRY OF ROSІYSKO RODIONS, VODKOVENIE IN POSIKOV VІD 3 PERSON 1995 ROCK N 4-P U PERSION PROGRAM 2201 І 2202 PDA RRFSR І Vіd 15 Січня ин и рук пот повірці стостуціностінос полож other article 295 CCP RRFSR, - the basis of all rights and freedoms of people and the necessary mind of their foundation and dotrimannya; Power z statti 21 The Constitution of the Russian Federation may protect the dignity of specialty in all areas, which assert the priority of specialty and rights.
The legislative, Spіvіdnosyachiyachi, its Dіlnіsti Principle of Vannanny Gіdnosti Osshistosti in the Sphey Spheres of Legal Regulation, the Zvaziyuchi on those, SEM SAME SAMIA Pensіya for his legal nature, this admitted to Popovenia Putti Ok'єєkivno Non-Zhivnoye Pretty mіnіmalny rozmіr trudovoї pensії on starostі scho zabezpechuє prinaymnі Taqiy zhittєvy rіven at Money Does s urahuvannyam vsіh іnshih zahodіv sotsіalnoї pіdtrimki scho nadayutsya konkretnoї categories pensіonerіv - not to put b pid sumnіv itself mozhlivіst gіdnogo Zhittya The Citizen yak pensіonera, zdіysnennya him іnshih progoloshenih Konstitutsієyu Rosіyskoї Federation of Rights and Freedoms of Specialty, and CIM did not apply to human fitness.
2.2. Such as the targets of the Constitutional-Rosіyskoy Aktіv, Scho є Warehouse, Rosіyskaya Aktіv, and SAME Rosіyski, and SAME SAME SKRIPLENIKI themselves from the social cobs'ov'jazan Rosіyskoi Federated obstavini, vklyuchayuchi dosyagnennya nepratsezdatnogo vіku, samostіyno zabezpechiti sobі dostatnіy zhittєvy rіven, viplivaє obov'yazok powers vstanoviti - vihodyachi of nayavnih ekonomіchnih resursіv - Taqiy order pensіynih vіdnosin, yaky stvoryuvav realnі minds for efektivnoї kompensatsії vіdpovіdnim personages vtrat od prirodnoї (vіkovoї) vtrati to zdatnostі pracі that self-sufficiency in obsіzі, scho guaranty їkhnu їkhnu material sаbаzpechenіє on the level, necessary for satisfaction of the basic zhittєvih necessities.
3. Realіzuyuchi pokladenі her Konstitutsієyu Rosіyskoї Federatsії that mіzhnarodnimi legal acts obov'yazki schodo garantuvannya dostatnogo rіvnya zhittєzabezpechennya sotsіalno nezahischenim kategorіyam population zakonodavets priynyav Federal Law od 1997 roku 24 Zhovtnya "About prozhitkovy mіnіmum in Rosіyskіy Federatsії" spryamovany, yak yogo preamble of viplivaє , on the established legal basis for the appointment of a subsistence minimum in the Russian Federation and its form, with the installation of state guarantees for the citizens of the Russian Federation of the minimum penny incomes and with the existing federal income.
Tim himself, the federal legislator, has vrahuvav, among other things, recommendation N 131 of the MOP "On assistance with disability, old age and spend a year old," by virtue of national legislation to establish minimum allowances for disability, weather in old age. to guarantee a minimum living wage (paragraph 23), as well as the Charter of Social Rights and guarantees for the citizens of independent powers, as a transfer of the need to establish a minimum pension amount based on the amount adopted in the state of the system of minimum statistic budgets8.
For zmіstom PROVISIONS Article 1 i 2 of the Federal law "About prozhitkovy mіnіmum in Rosіyskіy Federatsії" prozhitkovy mіnіmum Je vartіsnu otsіnku mіnіmalnogo set produktіv harchuvannya, neprodovolchih tovarіv that poslug, neobhіdnih zberezhennya for Health Protection is the Person of zabezpechennya Yogo zhittєdіyalnostі in Rosіyskіy Federatsії in tsіlomu that in subjects of the Russian Federation, and also includes obligatory payments and fees.
Three names of legal provisions, which are the normative-legal specification of the inscriptions in articles 1, 2, 7, 17 (parts 1 and 2), 18, 21 (part 1), 39 (parts 1 and 2), 41 (part 1) and 45 (Part 1) of the Constitution of the Russian Federation of Social Values, following that, in the system of civil legal regulation, the category of the subsistence minimum was chosen by the federal legislator as a criterion for designating the world of social assistance to the needy, providing for a living. ЦЕ и и и и и лозвій казості захонти стойной мінімуму, zoomovvyuyu соона поконочный зобовкольный коловая по по годаний постовый постанной подение пересій товина тование подение мотнования замині затстовійний на колененна замина за забенненние заковенние in every case, they act as a constitutional reference point for pension policy for the lack of financial guarantees for pension security at the moment.
According to the Federal Law "On the subsistence minimum in the Russian Federation", the category of the subsistence minimum includes the subsistence minimum in the whole of the Russian Federation, as well as the subsistence minimum in the subjects of the Russian Federation (Federal State); The magnitude of the subsistence minimum soul of the population І for the basics of the Social-Demographs of Rosіyskiyi Fedevyії's sub'єkta Rosіyskii Fedeitiyii Visnochuyu Schochvatalus Visit South Koshika Koshika by the Federal Body of the Queen Queen for Statistics About Rivane Software Troops on the production of Harchuvnya, Nedodat for binding payments and fees (paragraphs 1 and 2 of article 3, paragraph 1 of article 4).
When tsomu spozhivchy Cart at tsіlomu on Rosіyskіy Federatsії formuєtsya on osnovі serednostatistichnih pokaznikіv spozhivannya produktіv harchuvannya, neprodovolchih tovarіv that poslug gromadyanami Rosіyskoї Federatsії, and sub'єktah Rosіyskoї Federatsії - urahuvannyam of natural klіmatichnih minds Especially virobnitstva produktіv harchuvannya, natsіonalnih traditsіy that mіstsevih peculiarities of saving food products, non-food products and services, which formed the structure of eating on the basis of the actual saving of food products in low-income families (clauses 1, 2 and 4 of Article 3 of the Federal Law "On the subsistence minimum in the Russian Federation" and specifying provisions II III Methodical Recommenders Schodo Wrongs of the Software Keyboard for the main social-demographic groups of the population in Tsіloma in Rosіyskiyi fedsia in sub'єkti Rosіyskoji Federation, attendsee, the development of Rosіyskoi Federal District Vіd 17 Lyutogo 1999 N 192, in editorial Від 16 birch 2000).
In this rite, in the framework of legal chinnogo regulyuvannya prozhitkovy mіnіmum in sub'єktah Rosіyskoї Federatsії, zasnovany on diferentsіatsії mіnіmalno neobhіdnih vitrat gromadyan fallow od ob'єktivno obumovlenih pokaznikіv, Je naybіlsh ADEQUATE virazom mіnіmalnih natural require vіdpovіdnih sotsіalno demografіchnih-group of the population that odnochasno mіnіmalnim sunset sotsіalno -economic goiter of the state in front of the population, which are realized among them through the system of pension funds.
4. For the wedroom of the dysny zm_sti, paragraph 8 of Stattі 14 of the Federal Law "About Labor Pensії in Rosіyskiyiyiii" NefsInly Visnochiti Miscea of the Federal Law in the Systems of the Legal Regulation of the Social Systems of the Social Observation, Shah, Naku Speed Cathagorії Muddyan, Yakі require socially Ukraine, to jacua such that one hour a lot of social statuses (pensioner, disabled person of the 2nd group, veteran of the labor force, worker tilu), with the improvement of the totality of material and natural inputs of social support, as transfers for temporary work.
4.1. Іstorico-teleologicine analis of the legislative regularity of Pensіjniy Vіdnosin Svidatki about the demonstration of the tendencies in the federal legislation to Vіdmovi Vikodennya, the leadership of the Labor Pennsі's guaranteed by the Parameration of the 5th anniversary of the Federal State Unitary Enterprise.
Law of the RRFSR VID 20 List Falls 1990 ROPSR "Pro Perevnі Pensії in RRFSR" Posted by Mіnіmalniy Rosemіr Pensі's for Starista with a tanning labor experience, a rival need for a member of the Pension Pension (Statta 17), the Law of Rosіyskii Federal District About making amendments and additions to the Law of the RRFSR "On State Pensions in the RRFSR" - on the level of the minimum amount of payment of the pension (Article 3), in accordance with the Federal Law of January 5, 1994 "On the procedure for indexation and repayment of pensions, established by the Law of the RSFSR until " About the state pensions in the RRFSR "the minimum amount of the pension is not guilty, but the lower one for the minimum amount of payment for the work (Article 4), but it is up to the Federal Law of 7 September 2000 "On the procedure for establishing the allowance of federal scholarships" and no social payments rozmir, established by federal law (Article 4).
Federal Law Vіd 17 Breasts 2001 ROCK "PRO LOWERY PENSІNIA IN ROSІYSKIY FEDERY" ZMINIV NOT TІLKIO ORDER OF THE STARISTYY ROMIMIRA LOOKING FOR STARSІSTU, ALLE І ї ї ї ї ї ї ї ї ї ї ї ї ї ї ї ї ї ї ї ї ї з ї ї ї STATTІ 5 Labor Pensiya for Star_Sti Mozheti warehousing with basic, insurance part . In the event of the installation of the accumulative part of the labor pension, it is more likely to be charged for the obviousness of the costs, insured from the special part of the individual special account of the insured person (paragraph 3 of article 6), and also, the rule does not expand on the basis of the federal law for the formation of a pension strength, tobto. until 1 September 2002.
How to comply with paragraph 8 of Article 14 of the Federal Law "On Labor Pensions in the Russian Federation" in conjunction with Articles 2 and 7, paragraphs 1 and 5 of Article 14 that trivality, which means the increase in payments at the boundary of the insurance part of the labor pension for old age, that of the state pension assistance at the boundary of the size of the її base part, at any time - for the presence of the five-fold insurance period, it is independent of the obligation of the insurance premium - a guarantee, as a special right on the withdrawal of an old-age labor pension, the amount of pension contributions from the increase is not less than 660 rubles. Tsya sum of the day is the minimum amount of material pension security for old age, which can be provided by a hunker. Order z tsim s method of phased approximation of the basic parts of the labor pension for old age to the value of the subsistence minimum of a pensioner, the legislator transferred in paragraph 3 of paragraph 6 of Article 17 of the said Federal Law the possibility of their establishment by the federal law at the same time with the federal law adopted by the federal budget. what was implemented after 2001).
4.2. On September 1, 2005, having gained rank Federal Law dated 22 September 2004 N 122-FZ "On the introduction of amendments to the legislative acts of the Russian Federation and the recognition of those who have spent the rank, of the legislative acts of the Russian Federation under the Federal Law" amended and supplemented to the Federal Law "On the global principles of organization of legislators (representative) and legislative bodies of the sovereign power of the subjects of the Russian Federation" and "On the global principles of the organization of self-regulation in the Russian Federation". Yogo head meta - custodify of the system of socialist zahishtu ighistan, yakі cigarette pіlgami, the socially guarantions of that kind to the principle of Romeszeni, at Vіdpovіdn_st to the principle of Romesuvannya Renament MІZH federal authorities of the Divine Vladim powers with a socially-oriented market economy (preamble).
Paragraph 4 of Article 94 of the Federal Law recognized such that the rank was spent, Article 5 of the Federal Law "On the subsistence minimum in the Russian Federation", as I establish the basis for the determination of the minimum amount of the old age pension. Tim himself is a legislator actually changing the conceptual pidkhіd to the category of subsistence minimum of a hundred pensioners.
Togo, paragraph 6 of n 2 to the decree of the President of Rosіyskoji Federal region 24 Chervnya 2002 ROCA N 648 "About the leader of the acts of the President of Rosіyskoi Federal District in Vіdpovіdnіst to federal law_B" Pro Labor Pensії in Rosіyskiyiyij "TA" about Pensіin Rosіyskіyi "Bow of Visnanies So, Scho Gruting Chinnіst, Decree of the President of Rosіyskoji Federation Vіd 14 Chervnya 1997 ROCK N 573" About Come on Codniki Material Beating Pensіonerіv ", Skimno-Poisy, Scho Pickynaychi С 1 Січня инянь ина рукімальний помірна перміна Equally necessary for the recognition of a new pension, with the compensation of the compensation payment, transferred by the legislation of the Russian Federation, there may be less than 80 thousand rubles of the subsistence minimum of a pensioner, which is designated by the Federation in accordance with the law.
In this rite, іz legal regulyuvannya pensіynih vіdnosin boule viklyuchenі samі the category "mіnіmalny rozmіr pensії on starostі" ta "prozhitkovy mіnіmum" scho - at razі vіdsutnostі іnshih ob'єktivnih kriterіїv sotsіalnogo Relief scho orієntuyut on garantuvannya neobhіdnogo rіvnya normalnoї zhittєdіyalnostі osіb, SSMSC dosyagli Pensіynya Vіku TA є Under the Central Commercial Equipment of Grup, Veterans of Pratski, the works of Tila, - Maj Rotsіnyuvatiya Yak Keeping the legislant Vimoga, Scho Visitonє with the Constitutional Patterns of the COVA TA OBRION LYUDSKOY GDODNOSTІ, TAKE SKIN, HTO THROUGE ON'KTIVNI CHATING NATURALLY MANAGE material equality, the possibility of obtaining a minimum necessary set of social benefits, which, in the midst of a dignified legal regulation, is marked by the normative category "subsistence minimum in the sub'єktі Russian Federation" .
It is necessary to confirm the legal position of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation, pronounced in the Decree of April 23, 2004 N 9-P in the certificate about the reconsideration of the constitutionality of the other provisions of the federal laws "On the federal budget for 2002", "On the federal budget for 2002", "On the federal budget for 2002". the federal budget for 2004 rіk i dodatkіv to them: oskіlki, from one side, the federal budget is guilty of ґruntuvatisya on the principles of balance, reliability and reality, and zіnshoy - the Russian Federation as a legal and social power legal goiter, the federal legislator has the right to award the payment of six-thousand penny compensations, having no more transferring the necessary mechanism of exclusion;
For zmіstom danoї pravovoї pozitsії, znachimoї in sferі pensіynih vіdnosin, federal zakonodavets, vnosyachi zmіni in kriterії otsіnki mіnіmalnogo rіvnya of the Pension zabezpechennya result yakih Je znizhennya materіalnogo zabezpechennya vіdpovіdnih kategorіy gromadyan have razі guilty peredbachiti adekvatnі, efektivnі kriterії sotsіalnoї pіdtrimki have sukupnostі of pіdlyagaє timely indexation of pensions, which were covered by those vitrates, as if they correspond to the subsistence minimum in the region of the Russian Federation.
4.3. Viklyuchayuchi іz zakonodavchogo regulyuvannya pensіynih vіdnosin kategorіyu "mіnіmalny rozmіr trudovoї pensії for starіstyu" one of sutі, vіdmovivshis od vstanovlennya of the Pension zabezpechennya vіdpovіdno to a value prozhitkovogo mіnіmumu for gromadyan, SSMSC Nabeul rights otrimannya trudovoї pensії for starіstyu to the start of the Federal law "About trudovі pensії "ROSІYSKIY FEDERII" Z, the federal legislative by visiting the speeches, Schomyachnya rivodennya Kathagoriy, to Jaco, to sway І Gromadkanka P. Enebіsova, I am sanging the Social School of Social Physics, Scho, Johnny Publishing Plubіchi Vіdpovyky and not obezhuetsya less than a pension payment.
Thus, the applicant may have the right to apply for social assistance in accordance with the upcoming federal laws:
Від 24 leisurefaste 1995 ROCK "about socially zahist іnvalіdіv at Rosіyskiyiiiiї", Со Діє и и замомова з з и продания статі 154 federal law Vіd 22 SERPNA 2004 ROCK N 122-ФЗ ипукує, zokrema, Naddana Іnvalipa Zhtlovoye Primischennya (in the Budinkles of the Muni-Cipal Zhital Foundation's Budinkles) that payment of the communal ravines (Unanimlessly Vіdnzhnoshnostі Zhital Fond) (Partin of Thirtequate Stattі 17), and Torzozha Naznya ІНВідам ІІ GRUP С 1 Січный виплати ховірі и рошшива рублита помірі а 550 ruble from 1 September 2006 to the fate of the choice of a citizen, either saving the appointed order of the social support, or removing the six-thousand penny payment from the rozmіrі 1000 rubles (Article 28.1);
dated 2 April 1995 "About the social services for the poor and the disabled", about the transfer of hospital, non-stationary and home-based social services to the disabled (Chapter III);
dated April 17, 1999, the year "About state social assistance", the provisions of Articles 61 and 62 of which are transferred to the disabled such social services, as the additional medical assistance is provided to those who are provided with the necessary medical care, obviously (for medical prescriptions), medical indications of vouchers at the sanatorium-resort of likuvannya, cost-free travel on the primary transshipment transport, as well as on international transport to the month of likuvannya back.
Ozo, arguments of the statement about those, Scho ї Constitutsіinі Law, Zakrіpleni in Stattles 20, 21 І 39 Constitutsії Rosіyskoiiii, instructing clause 8 Stattі 14 of the Federal Law "About Labor Pensії in Rosіyskiyiyii", Shaho admission to the standing of labor Mensch, Chim value prozhitkovogo mіnіmumu in sub'єkt Rosіyskoї Federatsії, povinnі otsіnyuvatisya of urahuvannyam dії vsієї sistemi zahodіv sotsіalnoї pіdtrimki (low yakih bezposeredno pov'yazuєtsya of pokaznikami prozhitkovogo mіnіmumu, napriklad lіkarske zabezpechennya) poklikanoї zabezpechiti gromadyaninovі zadovolennya mіnіmalnih natural required.
4.4. In this manner, clause 8 of Article 14 of the Federal Law "On Labor Pensions in the Russian Federation" in the system of legal regulation of social security was established for workers, as if they were given the right to withdraw labor pensions for old age in the full scale, until the recruitment of Federal law Je іnvalіdami II groupies, veterans pratsі that trudіvnikami tilu, mіnіmalnogo rozmіru trudovoї pensії for starіstyu scho virazhaєtsya in sumі її bazovoї that strahovoї Chastain, yaky in sukupnostі of іnshimi taps sotsіalnoї pіdtrimki that of urahuvannyam zastosuvannya mehanіzmu svoєchasnoї іndeksatsії pensіynih viplat LUVs bi prinaymnі not nizhche for the subsistence minimum of a pensioner in the subject of the Russian Federation.
In protsesі reformuvannya sistemi sotsіalnogo zabezpechennya federal zakonodavtsyu slіd garantuvati zaznachenim ladies Taku value trudovoї pensії on starostі, yak in sukupnostі of іnshimi taps sotsіalnoї pіdtrimki granted a permission b їm zadovolnyati mіnіmalnі prirodnі require vartіsnoyu otsіnkoyu yakih - in the framework chinnogo legal regulyuvannya - Je prozhitkovy mіnіmum Rosіyskoї Federatsії , de stinks to live, and tsim did not put b p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p p s s p p s s s n p s s o s p o s s o o n s , s d iisnennya him as a hulk of other votes of the Constitution of the Russian Federation of the rights and freedoms of the individual.
Vykhodyachy z vikladenyi keruyuchis paragraphs 2 and 3 parts of the first article 43 and part of the first article 79 of the Federal Constitutional Law "On the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation", the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation
signed:
1. Paragraph 8 of Article 14 of the Federal Law "On Labor Pensions" in the first constitutional and legal clouding, which is based on the resolutions of the resolutions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation and the second appointment, which save their power, transfer the establishment of pensions to persons, and give the right to work to persons old age in full expansion until the day of service of the Federal Law in force, as well as for the disabled of the II group, veterans of the workforce, the minimum amount of the labor pension for old age, which is reflected in the sum of the basic and insurance parts, but without the combined types of totality and with the improvement of the mechanism of self-indexation of pension payments, it is no less than the subsistence minimum of a pensioner in the region of the Russian Federation.
2. Visnati Skargu Fedorіvni is not pіdlyaga, Fedorіvni's departure in Skiddannі Constitutsіynyy Court of Rosіyskoji Federation, osskіlki for Vishennia Decisions of Patin not Vimagaznnya Vysresenna Statthey 71 of the Federal Constitutional Law "About ConstitutsIn Socialist Republic of Rosіyskoji" Pіdsumkoviy.
3. Praise to the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation for tsієyu skarga residually that oskarzhennu not pіdlyagaє.
Head
Constitutional Court
Russian Federation
V. Zorkin
judge secretary
Constitutional Court
Russian Federation
Y. Danilov